Aleteia Subscription
Aleteia Subscription
separateurCreated with Sketch.

The hidden grief behind Stephen Colbert’s humor

STEPHEN COLBERT
whatsappfacebooktwitter-xemailnative
Cerith Gardiner - published on 05/21/26
whatsappfacebooktwitter-xemailnative
As Stephen Colbert prepares to say goodbye to 'The Late Show,' many viewers are reflecting on the extraordinary personal story that shaped his humor, gratitude, and unmistakable warmth.

For many viewers, Stephen Colbert has long been associated with wit, sharp timing, and the comforting nightly rhythm of The Late Show. With news now confirmed that the program will air its final show tonight, May 21, after more than a decade on air, many tributes have understandably focused on his comedy, his interviews, and his place in American late-night television.

Yet behind the humor lies a life marked very early by devastating loss.

On September 11, 1974, when Colbert was just 10 years old, his father and two brothers were killed when Eastern Air Lines Flight 212 crashed near Charlotte, North Carolina. In the space of a single afternoon, the youngest child of 11, from an intellectually vibrant Catholic family, suddenly found himself growing up in a home transformed by grief.

Over the years, Colbert has spoken movingly about the quiet strength of his mother, Lorna, whose response to tragedy shaped him profoundly. Rather than becoming hardened or bitter, she continued loving fiercely through heartbreak. Colbert once reflected that his mother was never bitter, only broken -- and that distinction seems to have stayed with him for the rest of his life.

What makes his story so compelling is not simply the tragedy itself, but the strange relationship between sorrow and humor that eventually emerged from it.

For years, Colbert appeared to carry the grief almost at a distance. It was only later, while away at college, that the emotional weight truly caught up with him. He has spoken about barely eating during that period, losing dramatic amounts of weight, and struggling under the force of emotions he had suppressed for nearly a decade.

And yet, somewhere in the middle of that collapse, comedy entered his life in a completely different way.

Improvisation and theater did not become an escape from suffering so much as a means of connecting through it. Humor, at its best, often comes from the same place as empathy: the ability to recognize human vulnerability, awkwardness, anxiety, disappointment, and pain. The funniest people are not always the most carefree. Quite often, they are the ones most acutely aware of how fragile life can feel beneath the surface.

Colbert himself hinted at this recently in an interview with People, when reflecting on his years hosting The Late Show. Looking back on more than a decade at the Ed Sullivan Theater, his overwhelming emotion was not resentment or exhaustion, but gratitude.

“I tried never to take for granted filming in the Ed Sullivan Broadway theater, having that tremendous audience or having the ability to work with the funniest people I know every day and make jokes about the things that make me most anxious.”

Considering the losses that marked his childhood so profoundly, that sense of gratitude feels especially striking. Many people would perhaps understand bitterness after experiencing such devastating grief at so young an age. Yet throughout Colbert’s reflections on both faith and comedy, there often seems to be a conscious decision to remain open to joy anyway.

When humor and anxiety coexist

The quote also quietly captures something many people recognize in themselves too. Humor and anxiety are often far closer companions than we admit. Some people tell jokes because life feels lighthearted. Others do it because laughter helps carry what might otherwise feel unbearable.

And perhaps that is also why audiences so often respond to comedians with unusual affection. Beneath the performance, viewers instinctively sense something deeply human: someone trying to create connection, relief, or joy while carrying struggles invisible to everyone else.

Colbert’s story also feels like a gentle reminder not to make assumptions about the people around us. The cheerful colleague, the endlessly funny friend, the person always putting others at ease may also be carrying private griefs we know nothing about.

Behind many smiles lies a story we have not yet been told.

And perhaps that is partly why Stephen Colbert has continued to resonate with so many viewers over the years. Beneath the intelligence, satire, and humor, there has always been the feeling of someone who understands suffering intimately — and who chose, somehow, not to let it close his heart.

When Colbert met Pope Francis

In June of 2024, Pope Francis met in Rome with a group of comedians from around the globe, including Stephen Colbert.

Drawing from Scripture, he said:

According to the Bible, at the beginning of the world, while everything was being created, divine wisdom practiced your form of art for the benefit of none other than God himself, the first spectator of history. It is described in this way: “I was beside him, like a master workman; and I was daily his delight,rejoicing before him always, rejoicing in his inhabited worldand delighting in the sons of men” (Prov 8:30-31)

He also told them:

You also succeed in bringing about another miracle: you manage to make people smile even while dealing with problems and events, large and small. You denounce abuses of power; you give voice to forgotten situations; you highlight abuses; you point out inappropriate behaviour. You do this without spreading alarm or terror, anxiety or fear, as other types of communication tend to do; you rouse people to think critically by making them laugh and smile. You do this by telling stories of real life, narrating reality from your unique viewpoint; and in this way, you speak to people about problems, large and small.

Read more and see images here.

Did you enjoy this article? Would you like to read more like this?

Get Aleteia delivered to your inbox. It’s free!